
We Pulled the Files — And Something Didn’t Add Up
FOIA requests reveal hidden evidence in cold cases that authorities may have overlooked or failed to preserve
On February 23, 2020, six-year-old Joseph Jo-Jo King III was found unresponsive in his home in Grand Prairie, Texas. His stepfather, Brandon Hale, claimed that Jo-Jo had become trapped inside a toy chest and suffocated. The boy was rushed to Children's Medical Center in Dallas, where medical professionals determined he had suffered severe brain injury caused by oxygen deprivation. Despite emergency interventions, Jo-Jo died from his injuries.
From the very beginning, Jo-Jo's biological father, Joseph King Jr., a homicide detective with the Atlanta Police Department, suspected that something about the official story did not add up. As investigators began to examine the evidence more closely, significant inconsistencies emerged that cast serious doubt on the toy chest explanation.
Investigators discovered that the toy chest in question was not airtight, which would have made suffocation from entrapment extremely unlikely. Additionally, testing showed that a mannequin approximately Jo-Jo's size could barely fit inside the toy chest, raising serious questions about how a six-year-old could have become trapped there. There were also unexplained signs of moisture found throughout the home that investigators could not adequately explain based on the toy chest story.
Another troubling detail emerged regarding the emergency response. Despite clear instructions from 911 dispatch, there were indications that CPR may not have been performed on Jo-Jo before he was transported to the hospital. This failure to provide immediate life-saving measures could have significantly impacted his chances of survival and recovery.
Perhaps most disturbing was the discovery that less than a year before Jo-Jo's death, the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services had already investigated the home and determined there was reason to believe Jo-Jo had been physically abused there. Despite this finding, Jo-Jo remained in the home with his family, including Brandon Hale. This system failure raised critical questions about why a child with a documented abuse history was not removed from a dangerous environment.
Ultimately, the medical examiner could not determine the exact cause of Jo-Jo's death and ruled it undetermined. This inconclusive ruling meant that no criminal charges were filed specifically in connection with the circumstances of his death. However, years later in December 2023, Brandon Hale's probation from the earlier abuse case was revoked, and he was sentenced to 10 years in prison for that prior incident, not for Jo-Jo's death.
Crime Junkie hosts Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat examine the physical evidence, the inconsistencies in the official narrative, and the systemic failures that may have contributed to this tragedy. They ask the central question that remains unanswered: What really happened to Joseph Jo-Jo King III on that day in February 2020?
“The toy chest was not airtight”
“A mannequin Jo-Jo's size could barely fit inside it”
“Less than a year earlier, DFPS had already determined there was reason to believe Jo-Jo had been physically abused in that same home”
“CPR may not have been performed despite instructions from 911”
“What really caused Joseph Jo-Jo King III's death?”